In a comment on another post, Thomas Brock asks:
So… Will these additions to AV services, the anti-spyware services, the media playsforsure services and the internet and desktop search services add to the monopoly charges?
Short answer: No. Everything Microsoft does with Windows has to be cleared by the Department of Justice. That was one of the terms of the original antitrust settlement. Reasonable (and not-so-reasonable) people may disagree over how fair that settlement was, but the DOJ holds the cards and they get veto power over lots of decisions. You can also be certain that any decision to add a feature has already been reviewed by a room full of lawyers.
My personal opinion is that security features belong in the operating system. Internet connectivity and Web browsing tools are an essential part of any computer operating system today. Forcing Microsoft to maintain an environment where users must purchase add-on products so that they can safely use core features of the operating system is just wrong.
Search capability belongs in the OS as well. In fact, it’s always been there; it just hasn’t been implemented well. If other people can do it better, more power to them. That’s been the model so far for alternative browsers, and it seems to be working just fine. Firefox has been downloaded 25 million times, mostly by people using Internet Explorer. There’s nothing in Windows that keeps me from downloading, installing, or using Firefox. This is a great example of a product that does a better job than Windows and is deservedly reaping success.
Update: Symantec’s CEO, John Thompson, seems to agree, according to these remarks from yesterday’s RSA conference, as published in the seattlepi.com Microsoft Blog:
On whether Symantec would raise antitrust objections over Microsoft’s decision to offer free anti-spyware protection to Windows users: “I’d rather fight Microsoft in the marketplace because we’re convinced we can whup ’em. So this is not about showing up in Washington or whining on someone’s doorstep about what Microsoft can or might do. To the extent that they violate the position of prominence that they have, be assured that we’ll be watching, but whining in Washington about press releases or pointing to left field by Bill and his team, I mean, of what value is that?”
Not to mention that the complaint would go nowhere.