A sneak peek at the new DirecTV DVR

Matt Haughey at PVRBlog ran across some info about the new R15 DIRECTV Plus DVR, as posted at TV Predictions. There’s only one very blurry black-and-white screenshot, and the details are sketchy. Highlights: The new service will cost $5.99 a month (hardware is extra) and will have a 90-minute live buffer. It will also allow you to “bookmark” a program, which is a nifty idea. There are also some vague details of an on-demand pay-per-view service that sounds a little kludgey. The hardware is supposedly due in October.

With any new DVR, of course, the devil is in the details. And given that this material is from a bootleg copy of a product manual, it’s difficult to characterize the experience of using the actual product. Meanwhile, DirecTiVo users can rest easier knowing that they’ll be supported for a long time to come.

Update: In the comments, Brian Hoyt points out that the R15 is SD only, and the long-awaited HD version is still under wraps. I’ve changed the headline accordingly.

Satellite TV growing fast

Lost Remote passes along details from a study reporting that satellite TV now reaches 27 percent of households. That’s up from 19 percent just a year ago, according to J. D. Power & Associates. Some of the growth came from people like me, who switched from cable. But most, according to Steve Kirkeby, senior director of telecommunication research at J. D. Power, represents new subscribers: “It is satellite that is picking up new subscribers, folks who’ve never had pay TV before. Their growth isn’t necessarily coming from cable.”

This week’s 20 random songs

You know the rules: Shuffle your entire music collection, click Play, and report the first 20 tracks, no matter what [*]. This week’s list is formatted as song title, artist, and album (in italics):

  1. Riding with the King, B.B. King and Eric Clapton, Riding with the King
  2. Night Is Left Behind, Yonder Mountain String Band, Live in Cincinnati 10-31-2004
  3. Rattlesnake Shake, Fleetwood Mac[**], Live at the BBC
  4. Forgotten Years, Midnight Oil, Blue Sky Mining
  5. Love O’Love, The Subdudes, Primitive Streak
  6. Mother, Sinead O’Connor and Roger Waters, The Wall: Live in Berlin 1990
  7. A’ Chuthag (The Cuckoo), Natalie MacMaster, My Roots Are Showing
  8. Silvio, Bob Dylan, White Dove (bootleg)
  9. What Is This Thing Called Love?, Wynton Marsalis, Standard Time Vol. 2
  10. Back in the High Life, Warren Zevon, Live in Nashville 4-11-2000 (bootleg)
  11. Fly Like An Eagle, The Neville Brothers, Family Groove
  12. Alive, Pearl Jam, Ten
  13. Mother Pigogne and the Clowns, Tchaikovsky, The Nutcracker
  14. Lady Cab Driver, Prince, 1999
  15. Concrete Jungle, Bob Marley and the Wailers, On Stage
  16. Why Walk When You Can Fly, Mary Chapin Carpenter, Stones in the Road
  17. The Big Room, Neil Young, Archives Be Damned Vol. 4 (bootleg)
  18. Casey Jones, David Lindley and Warren Zevon, Deadicated: A Tribute to the Grateful Dead
  19. Seguro Que Hell Yes, Flaco Jimenez, Flaco Jimenez
  20. Five Women, Joe Cocker, Night Calls

[*] My one exception is to limit each artist to one track per list. If the same artist appears a second time, I skip over that track. This week, Bob Dylan and Yonder Mountain String Band and Bob Marley would each have had an extra track on the list otherwise.

[**] The original Peter Green lineup, not the bogus Nicks-Buckingham gang.

DirecTV and TiVo get closer to Splitsville

PVR Wire has the latest installment in the DirecTV/TiVo feud:

It’s not really news, but it does make it official: DirecTV will stop marketing TiVo’s PVRs later this year, replacing them with NDS Group Plc technology, which is owned by DirecTV investor News Corp.

The word came Wednesday during Reuters Telecommunications, Cable and Satellite Summit in New York City. "The product we will market is our product," DirecTV Chief Executive Chase Carey said. However, he suggested that customers can still get TiVo if they ask.

The NDS PVRs have high-capacity hard drives that store frequently watched programs, creating an almost video-on-demand experience for users.

The NDS box will reportedly be able to handle MPEG4 format streams, which means more hi-def with less hard drive storage. It’ll be interesting to see whether DirecTV offers incentives to current TiVo owners to get them to upgrade.

And a prediction: It’ll be 2007 before the HD versions of these new boxes are available outside of a few test markets.

This week’s 20 random songs

You know the rules: Shuffle your entire music collection, click Play, and report the first 20 tracks, no matter what [*]. This week’s list is formatted as song title, artist, and album (in italics):

  1. Tato Wa Biso, Ray Lema, Gaia
  2. La Hormiguita, Juan Luis Guerra, Ni Es Lo Mismo, Ni Es Igual
  3. Only Love, k.d. lang, Invincible Summer
  4. Preacher in the Ring, Pt. 1, Bruce Hornsby, Spirit Trail
  5. Stuck Inside of Mobile (with the Memphis Blues Again), Grateful Dead, Nightfall of Diamonds
  6. Everything Happens to Me, Wynton Marsalis, Standard Time, Vol. 3
  7. Soon Come, Peter Tosh, Bush Doctor
  8. Compliment, Collective Soul, Dosage
  9. Can’t Even Be Bothered, The Charlatans UK, Between 10th and 11th
  10. Bass Trap, U2, Best of 1980-1990/B-Sides
  11. Listen to Her Heart, Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers, Greatest Hits
  12. Compay Gato, Los Super Seven, Canto
  13. Mojo Haiku, Little Feat, Shake Me Up
  14. Triad, The Byrds, The Byrds (Box Set)
  15. Winter, The Rolling Stones, Goats Head Soup
  16. 3×5, John Mayer, Any Given Thursday
  17. It’s All Over Now Baby Blue, Bob Dylan, Live in Brussels 12-Nov-2003 (bootleg)
  18. Your Love, Neil Young, Archives Be Damned Vol. 2 (bootleg)
  19. Whirl-Y-Reel 1, Afro Celt Sound System, Volume 1: Sound Magic
  20. Discipline, Joe Jackson, Blaze of Glory

[*] My one exception is to limit each artist to one track per list. If the same artist appears a second time, I skip over that track. This week, Bob Dylan and Wynton Marsalis would each have had an extra track on the list otherwise.

This week’s 20 random songs

You know the rules: Shuffle your entire music collection, click Play, and report the first 20 tracks, no matter what [*]. This week’s list is formatted as song title, artist, and album (in italics):

  1. 8 Cylinders, Yonder Mountain String Band, Live at Newport Music Hall 2-21-2004
  2. The Boy in the Bubble, Paul Simon, Graceland
  3. Love Song for No One, John Mayer, Any Given Thursday
  4. Shangri-La, Don Henley, The End of the Innocence
  5. Tension, Shadow, Heat in Da Place: Soca from Trinidad
  6. Don’t You Feel My Leg, Maria Muldaur, Louisiana Love Call
  7. Mama, ‘Tain’t Long fo’ Day, Dave Alvin and the Guilty Men, Public Domain: Songs from the Wild Land
  8. Trompe Le Monde, The Pixies, Trompe Le Monde
  9. Love for Sale, Ella Fitzgerald, The Complete Ella in Berlin
  10. I Will Never Be the Same, Melissa Etheridge, Yes I Can
  11. Boul Di Tagale, Cheikh Lo, Ne La Thiass
  12. Desert Players, Ornette Coleman, Virgin Beauty
  13. Fortress Around Your Heart, Sting, Songs of Love
  14. Dry My Tears and Move On, The Del McCoury Band, It’s Just the Night
  15. The Promised Land, Grateful Dead, Live at Universal Amphitheatre June 30, 1973
  16. It’s Only a Paper Moon, Nat “King” Cole, The Unforgettable Nat King Cole
  17. Autumn Almanac, The Kinks, Ultimate Collection
  18. Eight Miles High, The Byrds, The Byrds (Box Set) Disk 1
  19. Murder Incorporated, Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band, Live in NYC
  20. Mad, Lou Reed, Ecstasy

 

HDTV, MCE, DRM, and DCMA

My lack of connectivity last week kept me out of the latest round of the DRM debate. Chris Lanier started it with a very sensible post here. He makes the point that DRM is already a major part of the digital media ecosystem, and in fact most of it is practically invisible. If you watch digital cable TV, rent a DVD, subscribe to HBO, own a DirecTV or Dish satellite, or even drag out one of your old commercially released VHS tapes, you’re already dealing with DRM, and you probably don’t even notice.

Both Thomas Hawk (here) and Alexander Grundner (here and here, plus this related post) have jumped all over Chris with several passionate posts that essentially make three points (and I’m sure they’ll let me know if I’m oversimplifying):

  • Microsoft could support HDTV over cable any time they want to. The fact that they’re delaying this support is a stupid business decision and is bad for customers.
  • Microsoft is big enough to stand up to the bad guys in Hollywood. If they really cared about their customers, they would not give in to their demands for copy protection on HD content. In fact, Thomas asks rhetorically, “Would a better solution be to create a technology to capture a HDTV stream between the cable box and the TV, record it without restriction (remember BetaMax?), and fight the bastards in court? Would a better solution be to completely empower the consumer and scorch and burn the rest of Hollywood…?”
  • If Microsoft doesn’t preserve the open PC platform for high-definition video content, a competitor will. The most likely savior of the consumer and the open PC platform in this scenario is an open source solution for Linux.

Chris has had several follow-up posts (here and here), and there’s been a lot of discussion on various message boards about this. But these lofty philosophical and theoretical discussions so far have ignored the two elephants in the room:

  1. CableLabs. Premium content over cable is encrypted. That’s why only a closed box (your cable company’s digital converter or an approved DVR sold by your cable company) can currently decode an HDTV signal from cable. If you want your PC (regardless of what OS it’s running) to record premium HDTV, you need hardware, and that hardware must be approved by CableLabs. You also need the cable company’s active participation in the process, because every CableCARD-equipped device is individually addressable. In a post on this site about a month ago, I provided links to all the CableLabs documents on how the approval process works, and I noted that a wave of testing of PC-compatible devices is due to complete in August.
  2. The Digital Millennium Copyright Act. I’m amazed no one has mentioned this. The law is repugnant, and the Electronic Frontier Foundation makes a pretty convincing argument that it’s unconstitutional. But I have no faith in the current Supreme Court to overturn it, and unless that happens the DCMA is the law of the land. Those who say that Microsoft (or an open source competitor) should just say “Screw Hollywood, we’re giving you unrestricted, DRM-free HDTV” really need to read Section 1201. Circumvention of copyright protection systems. The civil and criminal penalties could put any company, even Microsoft, out of business. Just ask 321 Studios.

Look, if Microsoft or MythTV or Beyond TV or TiVo could get HDTV content into their platform, they would have done it long ago. Arguing that this is an epic battle of good versus evil without considering the technical and legal factors makes the debate meaningless.

Media Center already does HDTV!

Matt Haughey at PVRBlog gets suckered by misunderstands SnapStream’s Beyond TV 4 announcement:

SnapStream have announced their next major rev will include support for HDTV recording and playback. This is pretty significant, as HDTV support in software PVR applications is still fairly new, with MythTV’s HD playback in early stages. It sounds like Beyond TV will support at least four different HD tuner cards as well.

By all reports, Microsoft’s Windows Media Center is holding off on support for HDTV recording/playback until Longhorn is released next year, so for those running windows-based home theater PCs, BeyondTV may be the only choice for quite a while.

Commenters, including me, have jumped all over Matt for getting this one 100% wrong. Here’s what I posted:

Excuse me? Windows Media Center Edition 2005 has supported over-the-air HDTV since day one. The others are actually playing catch-up.

The missing piece of the puzzle, which no one has yet, is CableCard support. I’ve written about the details here.

Microsoft and all the other companies aren’t “holding off” on anything. The hardware to decode HDTV over cable needs to exist first, and it needs to be approved by CableLabs.

And of course over-the-air HDTV is no big deal. I’ll have a lot more to say on HDTV, cable, and the upcoming update to Windows XP Media Center Edition 2005 later today.

Update: Rakesh from Snapstream makes the valid point that their original press release made no comparisons with other software, so it’s unfair to say Matt was “suckered” by the announcement. He’s right. I apologize and have edited this post accordingly. Also, Matt has corrected his post now.