Hiawatha Bray reviews Windows Vista Beta 1 in today’s Boston Globe online. His snarky opener (with matching headline) praises Windows Vista for being pretty but lacking substance:
The new software sure is pretty. Maybe that’s why Microsoft recently dropped its rough-and-tumble working title of Longhorn. The new product will be called Windows Vista, a handle that calls to mind a ski lodge in the Rockies, instead of a bedroll on the Chisholm Trail.
Vista uses a new graphics engine called Avalon for drawing windows and icons on the screen. Windows feature translucent edges and hurl themselves onto the screen with a zoomy animated effect.
The toolbar with its familiar Start button is now black with glowing green accents, and the Programs listing has been revised in a way that keeps it from running all over the screen as you install more applications.
Still, after a few days’ use of Vista, it’s hard not to feel disappointed. Dolled up though it is, Vista still resembles good old Windows XP, only with a lot more bugs.
That’s funny. I could say the same thing about this review. The writing sure is clever and witty – too bad the review manages to make at least three major errors in the first page. Let’s review the list:
- “Vista connected easily to the Internet, but wouldn’t link with other machines on a local network.” You have to open the Windows Firewall and enable Printer and File Sharing manually. This process will be automated in later betas. (And it’s the first place that a knowledgeable technical beta tester would look.)
- “[I]t would not make friends with a Serial ATA hard drive — the kind found in most new computers. Good thing the test machine had an extra drive that uses the older parallel ATA interface, or you might not be reading this.” My copy of Windows Vista, on the PC I’m using to write this post, is installed on a SATA drive. Not every SATA controller is supported initially. If you’re doing the installation from scratch, you have to provide a storage driver disk (Windows XP drivers will work) during the first phase of the installation process. This procedure is documented in the readme file. To be fair, that document doesn’t mention SATA disks, but a Google search for “Windows Vista” install SATA turned up thousands of pages that describe the necessary steps.
- “[In the new Internet Explorer] you can’t drag its toolbars around to rearrange them, a pleasant feature of today’s Internet Explorer.” Unless you right-click on the toolbar (or choose View, Toolbars) and clear the Lock the Taskbars option. Once you do that, you can move and resize any toolbar any way you like. This feature is in Internet Explorer 6, in fact.
It doesn’t get any better on page 2.
- “Windows is notoriously easy to infect with rogue programs. Just ask Massachusetts workers who had to fend off last week’s attack of computer worms.” Yes, in a review of Windows Vista it’s important to mention problems that occurred with people running Windows 2000 who did not have a software firewall configured and who had failed to install a critical update.
- “Such things rarely happen to Apple Macintosh computers, or machines running Linux, because their operating systems block unauthorized programs. Microsoft says its new security features will do the same, and make Vista machines as secure as a Macintosh. Not a moment too soon. An effective security upgrade might help Microsoft overcome its toughest business rival: Microsoft.” Ahem. Had they been running Windows XP Service Pack 1, which was released in 2002, they would have been immune to this worm. The additional protections in SP2 would have prevented even more of the problems Bray ticks off. The baseline work on security has already been done and is available today. Bray doesn’t mention the actual security features in Windows Vista, like the much greater support for limited user accounts and a two-way firewall planned for later betas.
And what else didn’t Bray mention? How about the new Explorer, with a Virtual Folders feature that makes it possible to find documents very quickly and to save those searches for reuse? It’s the single most innovative aspect of the Windows Vista interface, but it doesn’t get a mention. The Quick Search bar at the top of every Explorer window? Windows Parental Controls? Might as well be invisible. A slick new preview tool for pictures and videos? Labels for digital pictures? Missed it completely.
A Beta 1 release of any operating system is, by definition, rough and incomplete. The reason this is available to developers and technical beta testers and not to the general public is precisely because of the issues that Bray raised here. I assume that a PR person for Microsoft sent Bray this version of Windows Vista. Even an hour on the phone with a support professional would have helped him work through every one of his issues. Instead, Bray paints a misleading picture based on fundamental misunderstandings.
It’s going to be a very, very long year.