Is Longhorn a “train wreck”? Uh, no…

Paul Thurrott got Slashdotted for his offhand comment about Longhorn: “This has the makings of a train wreck.”

Well, I noticed that the post was time-stamped 6:24 AM, and started out “I hate mornings.” So read the rest of the commentary accordingly.

On a more substantive note, let’s put things in perspective. The Longhorn build handed out here at WinHEC is for people who write device drivers for a living. It wasn’t put together to dazzle Windows fans or, for that matter, to be used on production systems. It’s got lots and lots of rough edges. The bits and pieces I’ve seen here look interesting and unfinished. But I’m going to reserve more substantive opinions until Beta 1 comes out this summer. And even then I’m setting my expectations appropriately, because Microsoft has already made it clear that most of the whizzy consumer-friendly features won’t appear until Beta 2.

This is awfully early to be making any definitive judgments.

“Social issues” at Microsoft

In the comments to my post yesterday on the Apple versus Wiley dustup, several commenters asked why I haven’t said anything about the controversy over Microsoft dropping support for the anti-discrimination bill in Washington State. The full version of this post contains my thoughts on this issue. If you’re here to read about Longhorn or Windows and you prefer to avoid political discussion, you might want to stop reading now.

Continue reading ““Social issues” at Microsoft”

Tip of the day: Managing saved passwords and form data for Web sites

The AutoComplete feature in Internet Explorer allows you to save form data and user name/password combinations associated with Web pages. Firefox offers a similar feature with some important usability improvements. Today’s tip tells you how to work with this feature in IE and Firefox.

Continue reading “Tip of the day: Managing saved passwords and form data for Web sites”

Quieter, cooler PCs

I just got out of a fascinating session at WinHEC on designs for new Media Center PCs. Nvidia has been researching heat and noise in PC design, with a special emphasis on creating PCs that are quiet and cool enough to pass the living-room test.

Heat comes from some surprising sources. If you select the right CPU, it will probably pass the heat test with flying colors. Under heavy loads (recording two programs at once and playing back a DVD), the most heat came from graphics processors, tuner cards, and hard drives, all of which easily hit 60 degrees Celsius (140F).

The challenge for the next generation of Media Center PCs is to cool down all these components and keep fan noise to a minimum and put it all in a case that fits in your audio rack. That’s a tall order.

Some great links on the final slide:

Case and fan designs:

Quiet PC specialists:

I have yet to find aPC quiet enough for my living room, which is why my Media Center PC is in the office and a Media Center Extender is connected to the TV. Custom home builders have been hiding audio/video equipment in closets for years; maybe this technique is ready to move into more modest homes.

 

Steve Jobs continues assault on the press

Today’s San Jose Mercury-News (registration required) reports that Apple is taking another shot at an author who dares to criticize:

John Wiley & Sons, a leading publisher of technology books, said Apple Computer has removed all its titles from the shelves of Apple stores in apparent retaliation for the upcoming publication of a biography of Apple CEO Steve Jobs.

The books disappeared from Apple stores last week after a month of increasingly contentious discussions about publication of the book, “iCon Steve Jobs: The Greatest Second Act in the History of Business,” said author Jeffrey S. Young. The book, co-written with William L. Simon, offers an unflinching account of the rise, fall and rebirth of one of Silicon Valley’s most charismatic figures.

The dust-up with Wiley comes as Apple is embroiled in a legal battle with three Web sites over their right to publish information about unreleased company products. The Cupertino company went to court to discover the source of information leaked to the Apple news sites. Several news organizations, including the Mercury News, have filed a brief in support of the sites’ right to publish.

Wiley books were not on the shelves of a Newport Beach Apple store Monday. Clerks at 11 other Apple stories said Wiley books were “out of stock” or otherwise unavailable.

The removal of the Macintosh-related titles, including New York Times columnist David Pogue’s popular “Macs for Dummies, 8th Edition” book, reflects the company’s fierce efforts to manage its public image.

I would completely understand if Apple decided not to sell Young’s book in its stores. But applying economic pressure on the publisher in an effort to get them to suppress the book or censor its content is reprehensible and shows a complete lack of respect for its customers. Apple has a completely undeserved reputation as an icon of the counter-culture. Through the years, their actions have been downright Stalinist.

The whole story reminds me of a line from one of my favorite Neville Brothers albums, Brother’s Keeper: “It’s freedom of speech. As long as you don’t try to say too much.”

Update: Welcome, Macsurfer readers. Those who object to the reference to Stalin must have skipped advanced political science and history classes. Here’s a good refresher from Wikipedia:

Stalin argued that … political repression was necessary … Tolerance inside the Party to those who disagreed with the official Party line was called by Stalin “rotten liberalism“. He believed such tolerance would make the Party weak and eventually lead to its destruction. As a result, he argued that purges were sometimes necessary.

Apple doesn’t seem to have a high tolerance for dissent, criticism, and open disagreement.

Update 2: Bob Snow asks “Is it just ego?” and suggests the answer is obvious if you Google for “Steve Jobs angered”. Heh.

Oops. Your mom just read your blog.

A local paper reports that kids in my neighborhood might not understand how the internets work:

A Scottsdale student reports on her blog that she did not have sex following Chaparral High School’s prom on Saturday. “As for my date . . . well, let’s just say I might as well have gone alone,” she writes. “But it was fun anyways.”

Meanwhile, a student from Tempe’s Corona del Sol High School returned from prom at 2 a.m. Sunday and reported on her blog: “No alcohol was consumed tonight by me, and I’m still a virgin.” But her mother, apparently, was not impressed. A follow-up message Sunday begins, “What I learned from my mom today: I am a horrible excuse for a human being.”

At least they didn’t provide links.

(via the Washington Post)

Auxiliary displays

Here’s a feature you’ll start to see on portable PCs around the end of next year. The auxiliary display is a tiny LCD-style screen (plus navigation buttons) embedded into the outside of a notebook or other portable computer. The idea is simple: You can check an appointment, look up a phone number, pull up a music playlist, or do some other light task without having to open the PC and wait for it to wake up. Great idea!

Media Center or cable? The debate continues…

Tim Coyle is out with a comparo between his cable company’s (practically) free DVR and his Media Center PC. He covers a lot of the same ground I covered in my three-way comparo back in March and reaches pretty much the same conclusion:

Media Center comes out ahead by leaps and bounds. Media Center has much more program information available and an overall better TV guide and user experience. While a nice try by the Cable Company, the TV guide information is lacking and the remote needs a lot of help.

Thomas Hawk points out what Tim missed:

A huge point missing though is HDTV and while Tim acknowledged that his Adelphia box was capable of recording HDTV, his Media Center box is not capable of recording HDTV cable TV …

I bet if you polled HDTV users and asked them would they give up their HDTV in exchange for a DVR with superior features and functionality you would get over 90% of them who would never do it. Once you have seen HDTV you can’t go back.

Tim has a standard analog 20” TV. For him, recording high definition signals isn’t an issue. I’ve got 32” analog TVs in the living room and the master bedroom. On those screens, the analog recording from the Media Center box is just fine. In my den, the big HDTV screen thrives on the beautiful digital hi-def image, but we save that for special occasions.

In my opinion Thomas overestimates the appeal of HDTV. If you force me to choose between HDTV and a DVR with acceptable standard recording quality, the DVR wins every time. A gorgeous picture that is only available on someone else’s schedule is worthless to me. I’d rather downgrade to a standard signal than be forced to rush home on Sunday night so I can catch the latest episode of Deadwood or stay up till midnight to watch Jon Stewart on The Daily Show. Not to mention the capability to back up a play it again when we miss a crucial snippet of dialog. (“What’d he say?”) The idea of everyone in America sitting down in front of their TVs to watch the same show at the same time was fun in the days when Lucy and Uncle Miltie ruled, but it’s just quaint now.

My cable company’s DVR is good enough. And as they say, good enough is the enemy of excellent. Despite some annoyances, the Scientific Atlanta DVR I get for (practically) free from the cable company combines the HDTV and DVR functions and thus “wins” in my household. It makes me willing to use their box for programs that I want to watch on the big screen in the den. But I still record three or four times as much content on the Media Center box, mostly old movies that don’t need to be seen on a big screen to be enjoyed. And I can’t wait till this fall, when I really really really hope that one box will do it all.

Microsoft’s “Metro” format aims to replace PDF

One of the most intriguing demos at WinHEC yesterday was a sneak peek at a new document format code-named “Metro.” According to Microsoft’s white paper [in Microsoft Word format] on the new technology, it’s “a complete specification for a fixed-layout document format based on XML that offers ‘electronic paper’ for use by any application on any platform.”

Sound familiar? If the spec succeeds, it would obviate the need for Adobe PDF files.

Metro will reportedly be backward compatible with Windows XP. You’ll be able to print directly to a Metro file, use a universal viewer (like Adobe’s Reader) to open files, and send them to any printer that has a compatible driver. Yesterday’s demo of a Metro-optimized printer showed off the capability to print color pages that have the same sort of gradients and shading you see on the screen. Metro-optimized printers probably won’t be ready until 2007.

The new technology should be in Beta 1, which is due this summer. Developers can get the full spec here