Joe Wilcox is probably going to think I’m stalking him. I’m not, honest. It just so happens that his beat is identical to mine, so we cover a lot of the same topics. In a new post this afternoon, he reports on evidence that Microsoft may soon restrict access to its new AntiSpyware program to those with “genuine” copies of Windows. Joe writes:
Microsoft pushes product validation before users can get the software. In September, Microsoft started a trial for the Windows Genuine Advantage program, which seeks to curb piracy. The program, which is not yet officially launched, restricts some downloads to users with validated copies of Windows.
So far, at least, Microsoft isn’t restricting access to this beta to users with activated copies of Windows. Unfortunately, Microsoft is doing a lousy job of communicating their policy. When you go to the download page, you have only one choice. Read the wording carefully. Under the heading, “Validation Recommended,” it says “This download is available to customers running genuine Microsoft Windows.” The word only is not in there.
When you click the Continue button, you arrive at a page with TWO choices. You can choose to validate your copy of Windows (using an ActiveX control if you use IE, or by downloading and running a small executable program if you use another browser or prefer not to allow ActiveX downloads). If you don’t want to validate your copy of Windows, you can choose “No, do not validate Windows at this time but take me to the download.” Anyone can choose that option and get to the download page.
I agree with Joe on the main issue:
I fully support Microsoft’s right to protect its software from theft. But I don’t see how restricting a security software download is consistent with Microsoft’s often-stated goal of security being the company’s top priority. I would argue that Microsoft might even be doing itself more a disservice than its customers.
Security should not be an add-on feature. It should not be restricted to people who are willing to jump through a hoop to prove their copy of Windows is “genuine.” And it should not cost a dime. Making every Windows computer safer from spyware and viruses makes the entire Internet safer. Creating a link between new security programs and anti-piracy efforts is contrary to the goal of ensuring that all Internet users are secure. That is the ONLY way to look at this issue. Will whoever is working on this program at Microsoft please get that message?
Ed Bott 